
Banner and Forum Designed By: Aurora Goddess
MODERATORS: xwpweb, LadyKate63, Tango79, Sais 2 Cool, Daughter of Tiaran,
JustSayNoToNutbread,
BluebellXWP, brabmuffin, Drawing Blood
| Author | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Gabfan23 |
Hurt/comfort Fanfics |
Lead | |
|
I have just finished a rare fanfic-one that deals with hurt/comfort (that's common enough) but has one of the charcaters not recovering fully by the end of
the fiction despite a relatively long passage of time passing. As a great devourer of fan fic, I do guiltily enjoy a good hurt/comfort story but find in the
majority they recover very quickly or are miraculosly aided by a God/magic woman/potion to recover. Other than the ones where one of them dies, they are
rarely left with a debilitating injury or a long recovery (there is one good story that I have forgotten the name of, set S6 sometime and Gabrielle gets a bad
shoulder injury and tries to hide it from Xena but she realises and they settle down after realising Gabrielle is unable to fight anymore). I know the series
was like that, rarely were injuries carried over (Joxer post King Con springs to mind as good continuity though). I am struggling to think of more than a
handful where there is no incredible and complete recovery. What are your thoughts? Don't care? Like it to follow the show and have quick recoveries? Or
like me like to see more than the odd one dealing with the harsh life on the road? And would any of our dear talented fan fic writers leave one of the main
characters permanently disabled or injured? Thank you for your time.
|
|||
TheJollyApe |
|||
|
I'd probably never write anything involving a permanent injury and/or disability just because it is a little bit too foreign for me. I don't think I
could fully understand a situation like that because I have no good personal reference point and it would therefore never feel true. So on disabilities no, on
death yes. For the right story I wouldn't hesitate to kill on of them. I like a good tragedy and a death is more manageable from a writers perspective, or
from my perspective with my personal experiences.
Otherwise on the Hurt/Comfort scene I'm somewhat of an amateur and I know very little, it's not something I tend to read. Though now when you mention it, I wouldn't mind a few recommendations.
Sais (banner creator) // PLA (obsession is a group activity) // EPE (meaning of life)
_____________________________________________
Octavius
![]() Amongst a rough crowd of violent, perverted people, she felt utterly safe. |
|||
MoyCullen |
|||
|
I've never read a Xena fanfic where any of the main characters suffers a permanent injury. Years ago though I did read an X-Files one where Mulder was
permanently paralyzed from a gunshot wound. At first I thought I really wouldn't like it, but the story ended up being very compelling and I did enjoy it
quite a bit. I wouldn't want to read a lot of them but I'd be open to the idea in a Xena fanfic for a change of pace if it was an interesting story and
not just a "woe is me" tome. I could see an interesting dynamic if Xena had to deal with the loss of being a warrior and trying to find new ways to
continue her life's work of atonement. Gabfan23, the one you mentioned about Gabrielle's shoulder sounds interesting.
|
|||
Daughter of Tiaran |
|||
|
I've written fics in which one of my main characters was permanently disabled/injured, but the injury occurred prior to the start of the fic....and the
fics weren't hurt/comfort. Does that still count?
I think in general, unless it's an AU or something like that, I would prefer to have my fics follow the show, simply because it would feel more "familiar" to the tone of the Xenaverse as established in canon. Of course, if it's AU or uber, where it's not quite canon, I will tolerate more deviation from the familiar tone of the show.
"Would you kindly....?"
--Charles Atlas, BioShock
|
|||
absinthe angel 777 |
|||
|
I haven't seen that many "classic" XWP fan fics that deal with a prolonged injury, or having the character deal with a permanent disability.
I've got a hurt/comfort story slated on my TO DO list in the future but I've got a number of stories to write before I get to that one. I think it's an interesting concept whenever it's done by other authors. Anything that brings out the emotional humanity of the characters is great. |
|||
dahllaz |
|||
|
GabFan, do you have links to either/both of those stories?
|
|||
Gabfan23 |
|||
|
I don't have the name of the shoulder fanfic which is very annoying as it is well written. And I can't remember where I read it either. The former is
http://www.academyofbards.org/fanfic/g/greenheron_spirit1.html I struggled to get
into at first but enjoyed it towards the end and the ending was very sweet.
Falling by grit jahnning has gabrielle living after being injured/tortured by Caesar. However it is not finished... JollyApe The athenum has a good search facility were you can select H/C stories. A couple of good stories are Beyond and Forever by Pallas and When it Hurts the Most by RG Heller. Both are tearjerkers. You'll need a box of kleenex at your side. Other good ones are Silences and Natural Causes by Mayt which are typical of mayt's writing-excellent- although I thought in both of them especially Natural Causes the ending was rushed and did suffer from "miracle cure syndrome". I have read so many where "miracle cure syndrome" happens. I must be a real depressive-give me a long difficult recovery and I'll be happy!! Daughter of Tieran do you have links to your fiction? (Sorry no more links but I am in a hurry, I'll try and log on later with some links. Hope that's ok)
|
|||
dark hunter silver |
|||
|
I don't write hurt, comfort fics myself but I admit I do like reading them if there written well.
Last Edited By: dark hunter silver
03/13/08 5:50 AM.
Edited 2 times.
|
|||
Gabfan23 |
|||
|
Here are the links to a few stories as promised. When it hurts the most:
beyond and Forever:
Silence by Grit jahnning (remember it is not finished, and I am not sure it will ever be):
mayt's fan fics:
http://www.ausxip.com/fanfiction/s/silences.html Others I thought of were L.Fox's "Bard Faith" (He writes fabulous Fan fic but I think this is my favourite's of his):
Anything by Enginerd is worth reading and she usualy has a h/c within the fiction:
Nice little story seen through the eyes of Cyrene:
Anything and everything from Baermer is worth reading and this is no exception:
|
|||
trancegem |
|||
|
Hurt/comfort fanfics lovers read this:
http://www.academyofbards.org/fanfic/r/rdelliott_justice1.html (Justice Satisfied )
|
|||
Daughter of Tiaran |
|||
|
Gabfan--I have links, but they may not be what you're looking for. It's AU, and the two main characters are Gabrielle and Caesar, Caesar having been
kept as a slave by Xena for years before finally escaping. He is the one who is crippled, and as I stated, the fics are not hurt/comfort, and in fact not
really romantic. (Well, mostly not...Caesar still carries a torch for Xena, believe it or not.
)
If you are interested, the links are Destiny I Destiny II In Vino Veritas Choices Heroes She of the Djinn Interlude: Suffering Homecoming Long Dark Night The Beginning: Death of the Conqueror The Storm Again, though, they may not be your cup of tea--just thought I'd let you know.
"Would you kindly....?"
--Charles Atlas, BioShock
|
|||

